What to do if…
you are asked to decide about moving a relative to comfort-focused care and you feel unprepared
Short answer
Pause long enough to get a clear “goals of care” explanation, confirm who the legal decision-maker is, and request a palliative care (or hospice) conversation that spells out exactly what changes and what comfort support starts.
Do not do these things
- Do not say “yes” to “comfort care” if you can’t describe what will stop, what will continue, and what symptoms will be actively managed.
- Do not assume the closest relative automatically has decision authority—hospitals follow state surrogate rules if there’s no proxy; ask who is documented in the chart as the surrogate/decision-maker.
- Do not let the discussion get collapsed into one word (“hospice”) without specifics about location, services, and what the medical team expects next.
- Do not make promises to other family members before you know what the plan actually is.
- Do not have this conversation while you’re driving, in a public waiting room, or with multiple people talking over each other—ask for a scheduled call or quiet room.
What to do now
-
Ask for the plain-language version and a written summary.
Say: “Please explain what ‘comfort-focused care’ means here. What treatments will stop? What will continue? What will you add for comfort? Can you write a short summary in the chart or after-visit notes?” -
Confirm decision authority right away.
Ask: “Does my relative have capacity to make this decision right now?” If not: “Who is the legally recognised surrogate—do you have a health care proxy/durable power of attorney for health care, or are you using the state’s default surrogate hierarchy?” -
Do a rapid document check while the team is gathering.
In the next 10 minutes, check phone notes/photos, wallet, bedside papers, or a family shared drive for:- advance directive / living will
- durable power of attorney for health care / health care proxy
- any POLST/MOLST (if your state uses it)
Tell the team if you suspect one exists even if you can’t access it yet.
-
Request the right consult: palliative care now; hospice if end-of-life is expected.
Say: “Can we get a palliative care consult today to talk about symptoms, options, and goals? And if you’re recommending hospice, can hospice speak with us about what they provide and where care would happen?” -
Ask the four questions that usually unlock clarity.
- “What are the realistic best-case and most likely outcomes if we keep disease-directed treatment?”
- “What suffering or harm are you trying to prevent by switching to comfort-focused care (for example, ICU, breathing tube, repeated procedures)?”
- “What specific symptom plan starts immediately (pain, anxiety/agitation, breathlessness, nausea, delirium)?”
- “If we choose comfort-focused care, what treatments are still allowed if they improve comfort (for example, antibiotics for a distressing infection, oxygen, fluids)?”
(This prevents an accidental “all care stops” misunderstanding.)
-
Separate ‘comfort-focused’ from ‘code status’ so you don’t get rushed into both at once.
Ask: “Are you also asking us to decide about CPR/intubation/DNR right now? If yes, can you explain the likely benefit and burden for my relative, and document the recommendation?” -
If hospice is being proposed, pin down the minimum practical details immediately.
Ask:- “Where would hospice care happen—home, nursing facility, inpatient hospice unit, or hospital?”
- “What will change about treatments for the main illness, and what stays available for comfort?”
- “Who is available after hours, and how fast can meds/equipment arrive?”
If Medicare is involved, also ask: “Are you saying they meet hospice eligibility now, and can you explain the certification/election process in plain language?”
-
Assign one spokesperson for the next 24 hours and reduce message chaos.
Choose one person to talk to clinicians and then update everyone else. Ask the team: “Who should we contact for updates, and when is the best time to call?” -
If you feel pressured, escalate with a calm script and the right office.
Say: “I’m not refusing care—I’m asking for a clearer explanation and a palliative care discussion before we finalize this.” If needed, ask for the attending physician, charge nurse, or patient relations/patient representative (often called a patient advocate).
What can wait
- You do not need to decide today about long-term family dynamics, inheritance, or “what everyone thinks.”
- You do not need to choose a hospice agency until you understand what level of care is needed and where it will occur.
- You do not need to draft new legal documents in the middle of the crisis; focus on confirming what already exists.
- You do not need to be certain about every future scenario before agreeing to a comfort plan for the next 24–48 hours.
Important reassurance
Feeling unprepared is a normal reaction to a high-stakes conversation that often arrives suddenly. The safest move is to slow the moment down, get a clear recommendation and symptom plan, and make sure the decision reflects your relative’s values—not the pressure in the room.
Scope note
This is first-step guidance to stabilise the situation, clarify authority, and get the right clinical support involved. Later decisions may need more detailed medical, social work, or legal help depending on the setting and state.
Important note
This is general information, not medical or legal advice. Surrogate decision rules and documents like POLST/MOLST vary by state and by hospital policy. Ask the care team to document who the decision-maker is and what the agreed plan includes and excludes.
Additional Resources
- https://www.nia.nih.gov/health/hospice-and-palliative-care/what-are-palliative-care-and-hospice-care
- https://www.medicare.gov/coverage/hospice-care
- https://www.cms.gov/medicare/payment/fee-for-service-providers/hospice
- https://polst.org/
- https://www.mayoclinic.org/healthy-lifestyle/consumer-health/in-depth/living-wills/art-20046303